Best Metal Detectors & Gear Reviews
Who I Am
I'm a passionate metal detectorist with over 20 years of experience in the hobby. Based in Scotland, I've tested countless detectors across beaches, fields, and historic sites throughout the UK.
My mission is simple: help fellow detectorists make informed decisions by providing honest, detailed reviews based on real-world testing. I purchase most equipment myself and spend weeks testing each detector before publishing my findings.
From budget-friendly beginners' models to professional-grade machines, I review them all with the same thorough approach, ensuring you get the complete picture before making your investment.
Why I Love Reviewing
There's nothing quite like the thrill of helping someone find their perfect detector. I remember the confusion and uncertainty when I started, and I want to make your journey easier.
Every review is an opportunity to dive deep into new technology, test innovative features, and share my genuine excitement about the latest developments in metal detecting.
Plus, testing new gear means more detecting time for me – and who doesn't love that? Whether it's discovering a detector's hidden strengths or identifying its limitations, I'm here to share it all.
My Review Rating System Explained
Overall Score Example
My overall score combines all aspects of the detector to give you a quick reference point. Each category below contributes to this final rating.
What I Evaluate in Each Review
Unboxing & Initial Setup
I carefully examine what arrives in the box, checking for missing components, quality of packaging, and clarity of instructions. I time how long it takes a beginner to get the detector operational and note any frustrations or pleasant surprises. I compare the included accessories against competitors and assess whether you'll need to purchase additional items immediately. First impressions matter, and I document every detail of the unboxing experience to help you know exactly what to expect.
Design, Build Quality & Ergonomics
I scrutinize every aspect of construction, from the quality of plastics and metals used to the robustness of connection points and moving parts. I test the detector's balance during extended use, evaluate the comfort of grips and armrests, and assess how well it handles typical field conditions. I check for potential weak points that might fail over time and examine weather sealing effectiveness. Weight distribution, adjustability for different body types, and overall durability under real-world conditions all factor into this comprehensive evaluation.
Key Features & Technology
I dive deep into the technical capabilities, testing each advertised feature to verify it works as claimed and adds genuine value to your detecting experience. I compare the technology against similar-priced competitors and evaluate whether advanced features are genuinely useful or just marketing fluff. From discrimination patterns to ground balancing capabilities, wireless connectivity to multi-frequency operations, I test everything. I pay special attention to unique selling points and innovative features that might give you an edge in the field.
In-the-Field Performance Review
This is where theory meets reality as I take each detector to various UK locations including beaches, parks, farmland, and historically rich sites. I test depth capabilities on known targets, evaluate discrimination accuracy, and measure recovery speed between targets. I document actual finds made during testing and note how the detector performs in challenging conditions like wet sand, mineralized soil, and areas with high trash content. Real-world performance often differs from laboratory claims, and I give you the unvarnished truth about what each detector can actually achieve.
User Experience & Learning Curve
I evaluate how intuitive the control system is for beginners while assessing whether it offers enough depth for experienced users to grow into. I time how long it takes to access common functions, test the clarity of audio tones, and evaluate display readability in various lighting conditions. Menu navigation, preset programs, and customization options are all thoroughly tested. I consider whether the manual is helpful or confusing and look at the availability of online resources and community support. The goal is to understand how quickly you'll be finding treasures versus fighting with settings.
My Final Verdict
I synthesize all my findings into a clear recommendation, weighing performance against price and considering who would most benefit from this particular detector. I discuss long-term value, potential upgrade paths, and whether this detector will grow with your skills or leave you wanting more. I'm honest about dealbreakers and limitations while highlighting standout features that justify the investment. My verdict considers UK-specific factors like typical soil conditions and popular detecting locations. I tell you plainly whether this detector deserves a place in your kit or if your money would be better spent elsewhere.
Want Your Metal Detector Reviewed?
If you're a manufacturer or distributor and would like me to review your metal detecting equipment, I'd love to hear from you. I provide honest, thorough reviews that help detectorists make informed decisions.
Contact Us for Reviewsreviews@joanallen.co.uk